Case Study – Replacement DX Coils at local Mushroom Farms

Replacement DX Coils: To those not aware, Kennett Square, PA is the mushroom growing capital OF THE WORLD! Kennett Square is also located quite close to Capital Coil’s sales office in West Chester, PA, and we get multiple requests per month to personally come out and measure DX coils that need to be replaced at these farms.

Mushrooms need a well-ventilated growing environment, and poor ventilation can lead to higher levels of CO2. Higher CO2 levels negatively affect mushroom quality and growth. Ensuring proper air circulation is essential for maintaining healthy crops. Mushrooms also thrive in high-humidity environments, but excessive moisture can also lead to mold or bacterial growth, which can damage the entire crop. Proper humidity control is crucial to maintaining the right balance and preventing costly losses. To tackle these problems, growers need reliable climate control systems, and that’s where Capital Coil steps in.

Mushroom cultivation, while lucrative, is not without its challenges. Running climate control systems for mushroom farming can be expensive, especially when using inefficient equipment. High energy costs can eat into profits, particularly for smaller, family-owned operations. One of the biggest challenges for mushroom farmers is making sure that the coils are working at peak efficiency because the conditions in and around those farms will corrode the aluminum fins at a faster pace than most other environments. As mentioned above, there are very specific conditions that need to be maintained for a successful crop, so the coils in the condensing systems that are needed to sustain those conditions have to be working at all times. 

One farm had been trying to repair numerous coils through different “band-aid” methods. None of these attempts worked, and the farm’s energy costs had skyrocketed when trying to get the same capacity from a failing coil.  One of the neighboring farms that had used us for numerous DX coil replacements recommended that they call Capital Coil to come out and assess the failing coils.DX Coils

After looking at a few of the units, most of the coils’ finned area had been eaten away by corrosive elements in the air. The OEM had not recommended any protection for the coils, which was why they failed far sooner than they should have. The new coils were to be installed in the original units, so the measurements needed to be exact. I also explained to them that any new coil(s) needed to either have more durable materials, such as stainless-steel casing and/or copper fins, or a protective coating for the whole coil. If not, these same issues would continue to occur.

The farm decided to order (1) DX coil with an epoxy coating as a “test” before ordering the rest. The new DX coil arrived a few weeks later and was a perfect match for the original unit. A year later it was still running at max capacity with zero damage to the finned area because of the coating.

Due to the speed that we were able to come out to the site, correctly assess the reasons for the coil failures, and make recommendations on increasing the coil’s longevity, they decided to order the remaining batch of DX coils from Capital Coil & Air. They also recommended us to many of the other farms in the area, so Capital Coil is now the main HVAC coil replacement company for many of the largest mushroom farms in the United States.

RELATED POSTS

OEM Replacement Coils: Repair or Replace

Why are HVAC Coils Copper Tube and Aluminum Fin

Top 10 Tips For Measuring HVAC Coils

Why are HVAC Coils Copper Tube and Aluminum Fin

HVAC CoilsIt’s really not a coincidence why HVAC coils use copper tubes and aluminum fins. Copper is great for heat transfer, and aluminum – while still very effective -is simply not as good. The first goal of any HVAC coil is to cool or heat. Heat transfer is always the first consideration. Cost is the second. Copper works well for the tubes, but would be prohibitive for the fins. You would need a compelling reason for the fins to be copper, and sometimes there are reasons to do just that. However, the vast majority of HVAC coils that you see are built with copper tubes and aluminum fins. That combination offers the most effective heat transfer at the most efficient cost. 

To begin, fins are responsible for a surprising 65% – 70% of the heat transfer on any coil, while tubes are responsible for the remaining 30% – 35%. Additionally, in order for your coil to work at optimum performance, you need to have a terrific fin/tube bond. Fins are known as secondary surface, while tubes are referred to as primary surface. While this may seem counterintuitive, the secondary surface is responsible for twice the amount of heat transfer as the primary surface.

The tubes are expanded into the fins, and for that reason, the fins become secondary. As mentioned above, the fins are responsible for 65% – 70% of all heat transfer that takes place in the HVAC coil.  When you think about it logically, it really makes sense. At 8 fins/inch or 10 fins/inch, and with fins that run the height and depth of the coil, there is much more fin surface than tube surface. However, it also points out how good the fin/tube bond must be in the expansion process. Without that bond, the fins cannot perform their job.

Understanding the role and importance of the materials used in HVAC coils cannot be overstated. There is a distinct reason why the vast majority of coils are constructed using these materials. While coils can be built with other tube materials, such as steel, 304/316 stainless steel, 90/10 cupro-nickel, as well as various different fin materials, none of these are as efficient or economical as copper/aluminum.

Capital Coil & Air is here to help you with any and all coil selections, and we look forward to working with you on your next project.

RELATED POSTS

Why Is Fin Design On HVAC Coils Important?

Top 10 Tips to Measuring Coils

Did You Know? Facts about Commercial HVAC Coils

Top 10 Chilled Water Coil Facts

Every Chilled Water Coil selection is about balance. Your coil selection balances the rows/fins versus the cost of the coil pressure drops/performance. Trying to cut corners on your initial selection may save you money upfront, but you will inevitably pay it back down the line through added energy costs. This is a truism for every manufactured coil.

  1. Fins cost less money than rows/tubes. A good cost-cutting tool when selecting a coil is to choose 14 fins/inch. This will turn your (8) row coil into a (6) row coil, which will dramatically lower your costs. If you choose to go this route, one thing to keep in mind is that 14 fins/inch will be semi-inconvenient to any maintenance crew tasked with cleaning the coil. Don’t expect a Christmas card from them that year.
  2. That raises the question of whether or not you can even clean a deep (6) or (8) row coil? In short, you can, but it is not easy. Chilled water coils are especially difficult to clean because they are almost always wet. Due to this fact, they typically attract dirt and additional particles that other coils do not. Generally, when cleaning a coil, most of the dirt get pushed to the middle, and for that reason, 14 fins/inch may not be the best idea after all. Chilled Water Coils
  3. Did you know that fins do approximately 70% of the heat transfer in a chilled water coil, while the tubes are only responsible for the remaining 30%? This is precisely why the fin/tube bond is so important. Without a perfectly crafted fin/tube bond, coils become inefficient very quickly. You pay for that inefficiency through increased energy costs.
  4. How long does a coil last? At what age can I expect my coil to fail? Unfortunately, there is no single answer to either question. Everything is dependent on a combination of maintenance, duty, and numerous other factors. If your initial selection was correctly chosen, and proper maintenance was kept, 15-20 years is a good timeframe.
  5. You may have a situation where your coil is 20 years old, and everything appears to be operating in good condition. There are no leaks and all looks ok. However, over that length of time, what you don’t see is that the fins have thinned and are no longer bonded to the tubes, and the coil is dirty in places that you cannot see. Again, while the coil may look to be running in top form, it’s probably only running at 60% capacity. Most likely, the tubes have also thinned over time, so when the next deep freeze occurs, you can guess the likely outcome.
  6. You really need to replace the coil, but have been told to make do with the current coil? To make up for the lack of efficiency, you might try to “jury-rig” your system. One method is to change the drive on the fans to deliver more CFM. This increases the air pressure drop, which in turn increases motor brake horsepower. Another option to help increase the coil’s efficiency is to lower the temperature of the chilled water from the chiller. We tend to mess with the system and apply temporary Band-Aids, when replacing the coil is the only guaranteed long-term solution.
  7. If you want to spend money wisely on a chilled water coil, simply make the tubes thicker. The tube thickness for a 5/8” tube coil is .020” thick, so increase the tube thickness to .025”. The same applies for a ½” tube coil, with a tube thickness of .016”. Increase it to .020”. By doing this, you get the added bonus of making your return bends thicker, which also helps to extend the life of the coil.
  8. Not quite sure about circuiting on a chilled water coil? You are going to have a hard time making an accurate selection unless you understand how to circuit a coil. Circuiting is really nothing more than selecting the number of tubes that you want to feed, and how many passes the water makes through the coil – depending on your GPM. Circuiting is one of the most important factors in ensuring that your coil is running at peak-performance.
  9. Curious about the balance between cost, size, materials, and maintenance? Every chilled water coil needs to be maintained for its entire life-span. If you’ve made your selection, and something seems off about the coils, chances are mistakes were made during the selection process. Some indicators include the coil being too big for the space allowed, or incurring out of control energy costs. What is the point of saving $500 on a chilled water coil if you have to spend $5,000 in maintenance over its life-span?

As coil replacement experts, we run into this issue every day. Our goal is to work with you to ensure your selections are correct the first time. The person in charge of budgets will be grateful to you over time. Capital Coil & Air welcomes the opportunity to work with you on your next coil project! We want to be your coil replacement specialists.

 RELATED POSTS

Chilled Water Coil Circuiting Made Easy

Chilled Water Coils & Moisture Carryover

Top 10 Things You Need to Know About Chilled Water Coils